Haunted Bay Logo

The Amityville Horror

The Amityville Horror Movie Poster

Dimension Films, 2005, Rated R, 1hr. 29 min.

The house!
The house!

George (Reynolds) strikes a pose
George (Reynolds) strikes a pose

Kathy (George) talks to Father Callaway (Hall)
Kathy (George) talks to Father Callaway (Hall)

Kathy gets a spooky magnet message
Kathy gets a spooky magnet message

A scared Kathy
A scared Kathy

Arguably, everyone has heard of the supposed haunted house at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island, New York thanks to a book and a 1979 movie about the Lutz family and their 28 days in the house.  Being able to say that a movie, especially a horror movie, is "based on a true story" gives credibility (and a higher spooky factor if it's in the horror genre) to a movie.

In this new film, it seems like not a lot except for the premise is based on actual events.  I don't recall the real George Lutz trying to kill his family.  But oh well, that's Hollywood!  Why let the truth get in the way of a good story?

The new story goes like this George (Ryan Reynolds) and Kathy Lutz (Melissa George), a newly married happy couple, move into a suspiciously cheap Long Island colonial house with her three kids Billy (Jesse James), Michael (Jimmy Bennett) and Chelsea (Chloe Moretz). The house comes at a bargain due to the murders of the DeFeo family that occurred there the year before. 

The family happily moves in, but soon George seems a bit off, and we watch as he turns into mad, creepy George.  If I hadn't known the premise I may have thought his madness was due to him realizing that he's a hot, fairly young guy who just tied himself down to a woman with three bratty kids in a house that, although cheap, he still has to struggle to pay for...  Anyway, George swings back and forth between loving step-father and The Stepfather. Unfortunately, the way he does it seems unintentionally campy rather than creepy or scary. It's like you want to point at him and say, "Get a load of this guy!"

The movie has a few scares and the first half of the movie is definitely effective as a ghost story. There are apparitions making shadowy appearances and glimpses of ghostly images. Chelsea makes an invisible friend who has the same name of the murdered DeFeo girl. Add a family dog that barks at everything and throw in a priest for good measure, and you get a few good scares. It does seem like the movie is building to something and then falls flat. It is no longer a ghost story but a slasher movie, with George chasing is family around with an axe and making facial expressions that are closely reminiscent to Jack Nicholson in The Shining.

All in all, this is movie is better than the 1979 version and will be enjoyable to some. However, if you are looking for real scares, make yourself invisible at the rental line for this one.

For those of you interested in the "real" story of the Amityville house, George Lutz has created two websites: 
www.amityvillehorror.com and www.amityvillehorrortruth.com.

Do you think we got this movie totally wrong? Agree with us? Or just want everyone to know your thoughts? Then start a discussion of this movie in our forums!

Studio Dimension Films
Genre Horror
Rating R
Length 89 Minutes
Color Yes
Sound Yes


Actor / Actress Character
Ryan Reynolds George Lutz
Melissa George Kathy Lutz
Jesse James Billy Lutz
Jimmy Bennett Michael Lutz
Chloe Moretz Chelsea Lutz
Rachel Nichols Lisa
Philip Baker Hall Father Callaway
Isabel Conner Jodie DeFeo
Brendan Donaldson Ronald DeFeo


Andrew Douglas Director
Ted Field Executive Producer
David Crockett Executive Producer
Michael Bay Producer
Scott Kosar Screenwriter


Reviewed by: Boolicious, Special Contributor to Haunted Bay 09/24/2005


Copyright 1997-2020 Haunted Bay
All rights reserved